Peer-reviewed articles

Failure to detect ecological and evolutionary effects of harvest on exploited fish populations in a managed fisheries ecosystem

Contact

Davíð Gíslason

Project Manager

davidg@matis.is

Authors: Fan Zhang, David Gíslason, Kevin B. Reid, Allan J. Debertin, Katrine Turgeon, Thomas D. Nudds

Version: Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences

Publication year: 2018

Summary:

Overexploitation and collapse of major fisheries raises important concerns about the effects of harvest on fish populations. We tested for ecological and evolutionary mechanisms by which harvest could affect exploited fish populations in Lake Erie over the last four decades, over most of which intensive fisheries management was implemented. We did not detect evidence of long-term negative effects of harvest on yellow perch (Perca flavescens), walleye (Sander vitreous), white perch (Morone americana), or white bass (Morone chrysops) populations, either through recruitment success or through alteration of maturation schedules. Current fisheries management in Lake Erie has been relatively successful with respect to minimizing negative harvest effects, such that the dynamics of exploited fish populations in Lake Erie were more strongly affected by environment than harvest. Our study adds to the evidence that effective fisheries management is capable of rebuilding depleted fisheries and (or) maintaining healthy fisheries. Nevertheless, fisheries management needs to move beyond the ecological dimension to incorporate economic, social, and institutional aspects for society to be better assured of the sustainability of fisheries in rapidly changing ecosystems.

Link to article.