Reports

Undesirable substances in seafood products - results from the Icelandic marine monitoring activities in the year 2011

Published:

01/05/2012

Authors:

Hrönn Ólína Jörundsdóttir, Vordís Baldursdóttir, Natasa Desnica, Þuríður Ragnarsdóttir, Helga Gunnlaugsdóttir

Supported by:

Ministry of Fisheries and Agriculture

Undesirable substances in seafood products - results from the Icelandic marine monitoring activities in the year 2011

In 2003, at the initiative of the Ministry of Fisheries, monitoring of undesirable substances in marine products, both for human consumption and products for the fish oil and flour industry, began. Matís has been entrusted with the supervision of the monitoring project. The purpose of the monitoring is to assess the condition of Icelandic marine products with regard to the amount of contaminants. The aim is also to collect independent scientific data on undesirable substances in seafood for the government, the fishing industry and buyers and consumers of Icelandic seafood. The data collected in the monitoring project will also be used in risk assessment and to build up a database on contaminants in the Icelandic ecosystem. Coverage of contaminants in marine products, both in the mainstream media and in scientific journals, has many times demanded the response of the Icelandic government. It is necessary to have scientific results available that show the actual condition of Icelandic seafood in order to prevent damage that may result from such coverage. Furthermore, the limits of contaminants are under constant review and it is important for Icelanders to participate in such a review and support their case with scientific data. This shows the importance of regular monitoring and that Iceland conducts independent research on such an important issue as marine product pollution. This report is a summary of the results of the monitoring for 2011. Assessment of the condition of Icelandic marine products with regard to contaminants is a long-term project and will only be carried out through continuous monitoring. Every year, therefore, the missing data is carefully reviewed, thus aiming to fill in the gaps. In 2011, for the first time, so-called PFC substances were measured in Icelandic seafood intended for human consumption as well as products for the fish oil and flour industry, but PFC substances are surfactants that have received increased attention due to their persistence and toxicity. The following substances were also measured: dioxin, dioxin-like PCBs and pointer PCBs, PBDEs, metals, as well as 12 different types of pesticides. In 2011, grayling roe was also measured, along with cod roe, gillnets and liver to assess the distribution of pollutants in these organs. Of the PCFs, PFOS was the only PFC that was detected above the limit of detection and the concentration of PFOS was generally low. As before, a small amount of undesirable substances was generally measured in Icelandic seafood in 2011 and no sample was measured with undesirable substances above the limit value.

This screening of undesirable substances in seafood products was initiated by the Icelandic Ministry of Fisheries and Agriculture in the year 2003. Until then, this type of monitoring had been limited in Iceland. Matis was assigned the responsibility of carrying out the surveillance program, which has now been ongoing for eight consecutive years. The purpose of the project is to gather information and evaluate the status of Icelandic seafood products in terms of undesirable substances. Further, the aim of the project is to provide independent scientific data on undesirable substances in Icelandic seafood for food authorities, fisheries authorities, industry, markets and consumers. The information will also be utilized for a risk assessment and gathering of reference data. This report summarizes the results obtained in the year 2011 for the screening of various undesirable substances in the edible part of marine catches, fish meal and fish oil for feed. The evaluation of the status of the Icelandic seafood products in terms of undesirable substances is a long term project which can only be reached through continuous gathering of data. For this reason, both the undesirable substances and seafood samples are carefully selected each year with the aim to fill in the gaps of the available data. Thus, the project fills in gaps of knowledge regarding the level of undesirable substances in economically important marine catches for Icelandic export. In the year 2011, PFCs were analyzed for the first time in the edible part of fish, fish oil and meal for feed from Icelandic fishing grounds but PFCs is a group of surfactants that have received increased attention due to their persistence and toxic effects. In addition, data was collected on dioxins, dioxin-like PCBs, marker PCBs, 12 different types of pesticides, PBDEs and trace metals. Samples collected in 2011 generally contained low concentrations of undesirable substances. The year 2011, lumpfish roes as well as roes, sperm and liver of cod were analyzed in order to estimate the organ distribution of pollutants. PFOS was the only PFC analyzed above limits of detection and its concentration was generally low. These results are in agreement with our previous results obtained in the monitoring program in the years 2003 to 2010. No sample contained undesirable compounds exceeding the maximum level set by the EU.

View report

Reports

The effect of fish protein digestion on the development of cod larvae / The effect of fish protein hydrolyzate on the development of cod larvae

Published:

01/05/2012

Authors:

Hólmfríður Sveinsdóttir, Jónína Jóhannsdóttir, Rannveig Björnsdóttir, Oddur Vilhelmsson, Hugrún Lísa Heimisdóttir, Patricia Hamaguchi, Annabelle Vrac, Gunnlaugur Sighvatsson, Steinar Svavarsson, Arnljótur Bjarki Bergsson, Agnar Steinarsson

Supported by:

AVS

The effect of fish protein digestion on the development of cod larvae / The effect of fish protein hydrolyzate on the development of cod larvae

One of the main problems with cod farming is severe declines in the early stages of maturation and the quality of juveniles. The aim of this project was to obtain a more complete picture of the effect of enrichment of food animals with saithe protein digestion on biochemical processes in early maturing cod by applying imaging methods and protein quantity analysis. The results indicate considerable antioxidant activity of saithe protein digestion as well as some effect on inflammatory activity. The performance of larvae in breeding experiments was rather low, although the growth rate was quite acceptable and there were few serious appearance defects. Treatment with saithe protein digestion did not appear to affect larval performance or defects, but there was evidence of stimulation of IgM and lysozyme production in the gastrointestinal tract and on the larval surface. Protein set analyzes showed that treatment affected the expression of cytoplasmic proteins, stress-involved proteins as well as the metabolic enzyme ATP-synthase. The results indicate that the use of saithe protein digestion can improve and even out the quality of juveniles if the quality of the eggs is deficient, but when good eggs are used, the treatment has no effect.

High larval mortalities and anatomical deformities are among the major obstacles restricting the development of Atlantic cod aquaculture. The present project was aimed at studying the effects of a pollock hydrolyzate supplementation during early developmental stages of cod on growth, development and survival. Furthermore, protein expression was evaluated as well as the distribution and intensities of selected parameters of the unspecific immune system. The hydrolyzate was found to display antioxidant activity and can be regarded as a feed supplement to the live prey items. The survival from larvae to juvenile in the experiment was relatively poor, with satisfactory larval growth and low incidence of severe deformities. Offering hydrlysate enhanced live prey to larvae did not affect larval survival or development. Treatment resulted in stimulated IgM and lysozyme production. Proteome analysis showed that treatment with fish hydrolysates has an effect on the expression of structural, stress and metabolic proteins. Overall, the results indicate that fortification of the live prey with pollock hydrolyzate can result in improved or more even larval quality following poor egg quality, however, with no effects if eggs are of better quality.  

View report

News

Matís staff does not leave their mark… ..and neither does anyone else

On the occasion of Environment Day and Green April, Matís employees took action and collected rubbish around the company's headquarters at Vínlandsleið 12.

There was no need to pick up the rubbish, as much had accumulated after the winter.

Green April 2012 - debris lost

News

Simulation of temperature changes in the transport of fresh fish products

On Wednesday 2 May, a doctoral dissertation in mechanical engineering will take place at the Faculty of Industrial Engineering, Mechanical Engineering and Computer Science at the University of Iceland's School of Engineering and Natural Sciences. Simulation of temperature changes during transport of fresh fish products.

See news on the web University of Iceland

Opponents are Trygve Magne Eikevik, professor of mechanical engineering, Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU) in Trondheim and dr. Jean Moureh, Refrigerating Process Engineering Research Unit, IRSTEA, France.

Dr. Ólafur Pétur Pálsson, professor and president of the Faculty of Industrial Engineering, Mechanical Engineering and Computer Science, will chair the ceremony, which will take place in the Celebration Hall of the University of Iceland in the Main Building and will begin at 14:00.

Abstract from the study

Temperature control in the transport of fresh food from processing to the market has a decisive effect on the spoilage processes of the product. Fresh fish products are examples of such products. The aim of this dissertation is to analyze and improve the temperature control in the cooling chains of fresh fish products from processing to the market through experiments and mathematical heat transfer models. The results of environmental and product temperature measurements in actual air and sea transport processes are used to design transport simulator experiments, where different packaging solutions are compared in terms of insulation value and the quality of the fish products they contain. The results of the simulation experiments are used to verify the results of three-dimensional heat transfer models of fresh and / or super-chilled whitefish packed in individual boxes or stackers on pallets under heat stress.

The results indicate considerable problems in temperature control in air transport, especially in the case of passenger aircraft, but less so in container transport by ship. However, improvements are still needed in some maritime transport chains. The importance of pre-packing before packing is demonstrated to maintain the correct fish temperature during transport, especially during flight. The same applies to frozen cooling mats, which are recommended to be spread as much as possible around fish fillets or pieces in packages and thus even out their cooling effect. Measurements indicate that a temperature difference of up to 10.5 ° C can be expected within an entire pallet of fresh fillets in poorly temperature-controlled air transport. It can be assumed that this temperature difference causes the shelf life of products in the corner boxes of the pallet to be up to 1-1.5 days shorter than products in the center of the pallet.

The insulation value of expanded polystyrene (EPS) is higher than that of comparable corrugated plastic (CP) boxes. In the project, a three-dimensional model of corner-rounded foam box is developed in the ANSYS FLUENT software with the aim of improving box insulation and product quality. Analysis by model is the basis for a new 5 kg foam box, which is now manufactured by the largest manufacturer of foam boxes in Iceland. Other heat transfer models that have been developed in the project include a cooling mat on top of super-chilled cod fillets in two types of EPS boxes and cooled fillets in a CP box without a cooling mat. Furthermore, models of pallets with chilled or supercooled fish are being developed to study the effect of location on pallets, size of pallets and precooling on the development of fish temperature under thermal stress.

The doctoral dissertation is based on six scientific articles and one conference paper. Five scientific articles have already been published or approved for publication in international scientific journals.

The main supervisor was Halldór Pálsson, associate professor at the Faculty of Industrial Engineering, Mechanical Engineering and Computer Science at the University of Iceland. Other members of the doctoral committee were Sigurjón Arason, associate professor at the Faculty of Food and Nutrition at the University of Iceland and chief engineer at Matís ohf., Magnús Þór Jónsson, professor at the Faculty of Industrial Engineering, Mechanical Engineering and Computer Science, Sjöfn Sigurgísladóttir, former CEO of Matís ohf. and Viktor Popov, director of the Wessex Institute of Technology.

The research is related to the projects "Simulation of cooling processes", which were funded by the AVS Fisheries Research Fund (R 037-08), the Technology Development Fund (081304508) and the University of Iceland Research Fund and the European project "Chill on" (www.chill-on.com). Matís ohf. provided Björn's research facilities.

Starts: 02/05/2011 at 14:00
Location: Main building
Further location: Celebration hall

About the doctoral dissertation
Björn Margeirsson was born in 1979 in Blönduós. He completed a BS degree in mechanical engineering at the University of Iceland in 2003, worked at the General Engineering Office from 2003 to 2005 and completed an MS degree in mechanical engineering at Chalmers University of Technology in Gothenburg in 2007. Since graduating, he has worked at Matís ohf. as a specialist, later a project manager and now a professional manager in the Processing, Value Added and Farming divisions.

Björn Margeirsson is married to Rakel Ingólfsdóttir, a medical student, and they have a daughter, Arna, who was born in 2010.

About the doctoral candidate
Björn Margeirsson was born in 1979 in Blönduós, Iceland. He finished his BSc degree in mechanical engineering at the University of Iceland in 2003, worked at Almenna Consulting Engineers from 2003 to 2005 and earned his MSc degree in mechanical engineering at Chalmers University of Technology in Gothenburg, Sweden in 2007. From graduation he has worked at Matis ltd as a research scientist, project manager and currently as a research group leader in the Value Chain, Processing and Aquaculture division. Björn is married to Rakel Ingólfsdóttir, medical student, and their daughter, Arna, was born in 2010.

The dissertation can be accessed on Matís' website, http://www.matis.is/media/utgafa/krokur/BMPhDThesis.pdf.

Abstract
Temperature control is a critical parameter to retard quality deterioration of perishable foodstuff, such as fresh fish, during distribution from processing to consumers. This thesis is aimed at analyzing and improving the temperature management in fresh fish chill chains from processing to market by means of experiments and numerical heat transfer modeling. Ambient and product temperatures are mapped in real multi-modal distribution chains, which are both sea and air based. The results serve as a basis for simulation experiments, in which different packaging units and solutions are compared with respect to thermal insulation and product quality maintenance and more optimal ones are proposed. The experimental results are used to validate 3-D heat transfer models of fresh or superchilled whitefish, packaged in single boxes or multiple boxes assembled on a pallet, under thermal load.

Much more severe temperature control problems are measured in air transport chains, especially in passenger airplanes, compared to sea transport. However, space for improvement in sea transport chains has also been discovered. The results underline the importance of precooling whitefish products before packaging for air freight and applying well distributed cooling packs inside the packaging. The results imply that product temperature differences of up to 10.5 ° C can occur in a non-superchilled fresh fish pallet load and the storage life difference between the most and the least sensitive boxes on a full size pallet in a real air transport chain can exceed 1–1.5 days. It is demonstrated that even though a widely used expanded polystyrene (EPS) box design with sharp corners offers better thermal insulation than a corrugated plastic (CP) box, the sharp-corner design can be significantly improved. Such design improvement has been accomplished by developing a numerical heat transfer model in ANSYS FLUENT resulting in a new 5-kg EPS box currently manufactured by the largest EPS box manufacturer in Iceland. Other temperature-predictive models of products, developed and validated in this thesis, consider a cooling pack on top of superchilled cod packaged in two types of EPS boxes, compared to fresh fish packaged in a CP box without a cooling pack. Finally, models are developed for pallet loads of different sizes containing either chilled or superchilled fish. The models are used to confirm the temperature-maintaining effect of precooling and estimate the effect of pallet stack size.

News

Addition of omega-3 fatty acids to fish balls to increase nutritional value

The project Enriched seafood which was done in collaboration between Matís and Grímur kokk in the Westman Islands and Iceprotein in Sauðárkrókur is now coming to an end.

Several prototypes of products from Icelandic seafood were developed there, to which biomaterials from Icelandic seafood have been added, such as algae extract with defined bioactivity, hydrolysates to increase protein content and fish oil to increase omega-3 fatty acids.
The results show that it is possible to increase the amount of omega-3 fatty acids in fish balls without compromising the taste quality. The same can be said about the addition of algae powder and also succeeded in increasing the amount of protein in the fish balls. As a tool for active and successful product development with the participation of consumers, two focus groups of people were obtained to gain insight into consumers' experiences and knowledge about enrichment, enriched seafood, their consumption of seafood and food supplements and health-related lifestyles.

Consumer surveys were conducted to examine consumers' tastes for the prototypes compared to traditional products already on the market. Information on the bioactive substances and their activity influenced how people liked the products. The effect of the information depended on various factors, such as attitudes towards health and food, attitudes towards the ingredients of the product tested, as well as factors such as age and education.

An online consumer survey of more than 500 people showed that people are generally more positive about enrichment in the case of known hygiene products such as omega-3. It is also better to provide information on effectiveness even if it is a known substance, as it enhances people's positive experience of the product. Enrichment with kelp also seems to be a viable option as information on the use value of kelp in the product was given and the same can be said regarding fish protein. These products generally appeal more to people who focus on food hygiene, which is a fairly large group according to these findings. In general, it can be concluded from these results that the enrichment of seafood is a realistic possibility, but labeling and information to consumers must be considered.

In this project, experience was created at Matís, which will be further developed and used by other companies in product development and marketing of target foods, where consumers' wishes will be taken into account. Consumer surveys showed that it is very important how the marketing of such products will take place in order to reach selected consumer groups who are interested in such a targeted diet. The step has been a step forward in which bioactive substances have been added to ready-made consumer products. A very important result of this project is that in 2011 a grant was obtained from the Nordic Innovation Fund, NICe, to continue larger projects in this field and thus contribute to the increased value of seafood and marine life.

For further information Emilia Martinsdóttir at Matís.

News

Matís employee honored

Sigurjón Arason, chief engineer at Matís, was honored by the Icelandic Society of Engineers on the association's 100th anniversary.

On the first day of summer, 19 April, the Icelandic Society of Engineers turned 100 years old.

On that day, the company awarded the VFÍ Century Award in three categories and Sigurjón Arason, chief engineer at Matís and previously at the Fisheries Research Institute, received recognition in the category "They plowed the field".

VFÍ 100 year old Sigurjón Arason
VFÍ 100 years: Sigurjón Arason in the middle of the picture

Sigurjón was honored for his initiative and exceptional perseverance in implementing a number of innovations that have been crucial for the quality and profitable utilization of raw materials from marine catches and for the dissemination of knowledge in Iceland and abroad.

News

Summer jobs 2012

Matís offers a wide range of interesting research-related summer jobs in the summer of 2012, and students are encouraged to submit a job application.  

We are looking for university students to work on research projects and service measurements in the fields of food science, engineering, pharmacology, computer science, law and natural sciences. Further information on the research projects that are available can be found here.

News

Food and sustainable tourism

Do you want to take part in expanding the path of local food in the tourism industry?

Symposium in Hvolnar Hvolsvöllur
April 24, 2012, 1: 00-4: 00 p.m.

Tourism is one of the industries that has been seen as a growth driver in the countryside. Despite strong growth in the sector over the last decade, this has not resulted in increased economic growth in rural areas. This indicates a large economic leak when it comes to the consumption of tourists in local areas. One way to increase the economic impact of tourism in rural areas and reduce leakage is to build links with local food production.

  • What is sustainability? What can I do and how?
  • Opportunities in tourism related to food.
  • Measures to increase sustainability in tourism in the South?

Agenda
13:00 Seminar set.
Tinna Björk Arnardóttir, NMÍ

13:10 Food and sustainable tourism. Opportunity, collaboration.
Guðjón Þorkelsson, Matís  

13:40 Sustainability, the situation in Iceland.
Stefán Gíslason, Environice

14:10 Coffee break

14:30 Sustainable community in Sólheimar in Grímsnes, food and tourism
Erlendur Pálsson, Sólheimar

15:00 Katluafurðir - Experiences from the region

15:30 Summary and discussion
Tinna Björk Arnardóttir, NMÍ

Admission free
Moderator Tinna Björk Arnardóttir, Innovation Center
More information at TinnaBjork@nmi.is

News

Icelandic ingenuity in Tanzania

Matís' two employees were in Tanzania for a few days recently to guide them on how to set up a solar oven to dry fish. An interesting story about this appeared in Stöðvar 2's news, but Hugrún Halldórsdóttir, a journalist, was curious about this interesting project.

The news from Station 2 can be found here and here.

More about the project
Fishing and processing advice in Tanzania
In the autumn of 2011, Matís signed a contract with the Tanzanian government for a project on Lake Tanganyika in Tanzania. The project is funded by a loan from the Nordic Development Fund (NDF) based in Helsinki. The project was put out to tender in the Nordic countries and Matís won the tender.

Lake Tanganyika is one of the largest freshwater lakes in the world, almost 19,000 square kilometers in size. The lake is also the second deepest freshwater in the world, 1500 meters where it is deepest. Four countries border the lake, i.e. Tanzania, Congo, Burundi and Zambia. Tanzanians fish in Tanganyika, but both fishing and processing are primitive. Matís' project is, among other things, to assist in the development of methods to make better use of the fish and make it more valuable.

Matís has agreed with the Icelandic companies Ráðgarður Skipráðgjöf ehf. and Verkfræðistofa Jóhann Indriðason ehf. (VJI) for part of the project. Ráðgarður will provide advice and oversee the construction of a specialized vessel to be used for research on Tanganyika and fish stocks in the lake, while the VJI engineering office will manage procurement for the project. In addition, Matís has entered into an agreement with the company Goch in Tanzania, which will handle the socio-economic part of the project and communication with fishing communities on Lake Tanganyika.

"This project is a great challenge for us because the conditions there are all very primitive and different from what we know. We thus need to find ways to develop fish processing based on what is available, but we can not afford to have electricity, oil or other energy sources as elsewhere. A big part of the project is then about training and teaching the locals how to handle the fish and we will send people from us who will choose a few villages by the lake and guide the residents. It can therefore be said that part of the project will be carried out here at home and at later stages we will then work according to our plans on site. This will be a very exciting project that we expect to culminate in 2012, "says Oddur Már Gunnarsson, division manager at Matís, who is also the project manager of the Tanzania project. Together with him, Margeir Gissurarson, project manager at the Matís project, manages.

Further information: Oddur Már Gunnarsson

News

Primex wins the Iceland Innovation Award 2012

The company Primex won the Iceland Innovation Award 2012 right now. Matís sincerely congratulates the employees of Primex on the award. There has been a very good collaboration between Primex and Matis and one of the company's employees is located in Matís' premises at Vínlandsleið in Grafarholt.

Matís has now worked with Primex on a number of projects for a long time. One of these projects is to develop a method to extend the shelf life of fresh seafood with chitosan, which has both antimicrobial and antioxidant effects. The benefits are increased shelf life, improved quality and safety. This innovation will lead to an increase in the value of seafood and at the same time be useful for other foods.

More about the award ceremony (from Rannís website, www.rannis.is)
At Nýsköpunarþing, the management of innovation was made a topic of discussion and four members of the business community were invited to share their experiences and projects in this field. More than 200 people attended the congress, which was held at the Grand Hotel Reykjavík.

Primex, founded in 1997 and located in Siglufjörður, produces chitin and chitosan from shrimp shells. Chitosan is a valuable and sought-after material, especially in foreign markets, and the company has gained a good market position in the United States, Asia and Europe, in addition to which the company recently entered the market in Russia. The properties of chitosan are used in the production of food supplements, wound care products and cosmetics as well as being used in wine production and food. In food production, the material is used as a natural fiber and preservative, and this new use has opened up more opportunities for the company. Primex has received ISO 22000 standard certification which ensures safety in food production.

What used to be waste is now raw material
The original idea for the company was how to increase the utilization of marine products by utilizing waste as a raw material and at the same time respecting environmental considerations. Shrimp shells are very environmentally polluting, but they have been thrown into the sea for years. After learning about the possibilities and opportunities of the material chitosan and getting acquainted with production methods and markets, the companies Rammi in Siglufjörður and Síldarvinnsla ríkisins decided to establish a company around the idea and build a factory in Siglufjörður. The company Kítín, later Primex, was formed, which began production of the chitin and chitosan in 1999. An agreement was made with the American company Vanson in 2004 for the purchase of knowledge to build a factory and for a patent for the LipoSan Ultra brand. Vanson was then the largest producer of chitosan in the United States but moved all its production to Siglufjörður. With this, markets opened up in the United States for Primex, but mainly for chitosan in food supplements and cosmetics.  

Production of own consumer products
LipoSan is a fat binder with natural fibers that chitosan contains and has the unique property of absorbing fat. The product is intended for those who need to control their body weight and improve digestion. Studies have also shown the substance's ability to lower cholesterol. LipoSan products are available in all major pharmacies in the country, as well as health food stores. ChitoClear, on the other hand, is a wound spray and gel for animals and the substance is very healing and reduces pain and itching in and around wounds. In addition, it works against bacterial and fungal growth. ChitoClear has been sold in Iceland and Germany. ChitoClear has mainly been marketed for animals but the material is also good for humans. Since 2001, Primex has been selling chitosan to companies in Europe and the United States that manufacture products to stop bleeding and heal wounds. In 2004, the company was recognized for chitosan patches as one of the top ten military inventions, which have been used, among other things, on the battlefield in Iraq, where they saved the lives of hundreds of soldiers.

The future is based on the export of chitosan
In future, Primex's production will be based on the export of chitosan as a raw material for other manufacturers. At the same time, the possibility of diversifying the production of own consumer products, such as cosmetics and healing ointments, is being examined. The possibility of producing protein from waste from shell processing to aquaculture feed production is also being examined, but the shrimp shells that Primex uses come from Rammar hf.'s shrimp factories. in Siglufjörður and Dögun in Sauðárkrókur. Icelandic chitosan is a high-quality material and there is a lot of development work and research on the activity of the material behind the production. The quality has enabled the company to enter a more valuable market. The company now employs fifteen specially trained employees who have put the company on the map in demanding markets abroad.

Innovation Award Iceland 2012
The Iceland Innovation Prize is awarded by Rannís, Íslandsstofa, Nýsköpunarmiðstöð Íslands and Nýsköpunarsjóður atvinnulífsins, to companies that are considered to have excelled in the development of new products or services based on research and scientific work and have achieved market success. The purpose of the award is to draw attention to the important connections that exist between research and the acquisition of knowledge and increased value creation in the business sector. The prize is a statue of the fertility god Frey by sculptor Hallstein Sigurðsson.

When choosing a prize winner, consideration is given to whether it is a new start-up company, whether it is based on innovative technology and ideas and is demanding of knowledge. It also assesses the value added of products and whether the company has been successful in the market. It is assessed whether the company is likely to hold its own and whether the management of innovation is exemplary. Finally, it is assessed whether the company is an incentive for others to follow the same path.

EN